A monkey takes a selfie. Who owns the copyright?
Wait — this actually happened?
Indonesia, 2011. A monkey took selfies using wildlife photographer David Slater's camera. His camera; the monkey's selfie. So who gets the copyright?
Then came the lawyers
In 2015, PETA filed a US lawsuit on behalf of a monkey it identified as Naruto, arguing that Naruto took the selfies, so the copyright should be his. Can a monkey sue?
The court said no
On 23 April 2018 a US appeals court ruled that animals cannot bring copyright infringement claims under the US Copyright Act. One important detail: the ruling did not establish that Slater owned the copyright in the selfies. Winning isn't owning.
Copyright needs a human
In the US, copyright requires human authorship — the US Copyright Office will not register a photo created entirely by a monkey. The camera is only a tool.
Do you agree with the court's decision? Tell us in the comments.
Sources: Naruto v Slater (2018); US Copyright Office Compendium §§306, 313.2.
Comments